This or That? Tag: Holiday Makeup 2017

This is my take on the ‘This or that’ makeup tag, which sort of combines a wishlist with an anti-haul. Today I’m going to be sharing which holiday items I’d take, and which ones I’d leave behind from a few of my favourite cruelty-free brands.

Hourglass Ambient: Lighting Edit Volume 3 or Metallic Strobe Lighting Palette

This was an easy choice! I loved last year’s Ambient Edit palette, and was sad I missed out on the 2015 edition. This one has an even better selection of colours than last year, and if the formula is the same, I already know I’ll love it! And of course, the packaging is just beautiful in Rose Gold. While the Strobing powders are beautiful, the shade selection doesn’t wow me, and I feel like I get more variety with the face palette.

Hourglass Holiday 2017 ToT

Image source: Hourglass Cosmetics

Becca Après Ski Glow Collection: Face or Eye Lights Palette

This choice was a lot harder than I thought. After reading Temptalia’s review (more like roast) of the Eye Lights palette, I thought I’d buy the face palette instead. However, as I’m getting the Hourglass Ambient Lighting Edit Volume 3 face palette, it seems silly to get something with a very similar concept (highlights, blushes and bronzer). The eyeshadows seem more like toppers according to other reviews, but I do feel like I’ll get a lot of wear out of these highlighters too. I love that they included Rose Quartz in both holiday palettes, so if you missed out on the full size compact, definitely scoop one of these up!

Becca Holiday 2017 ToT

Image source: BECCA Cosmetics

Tarte: Blush Bazaar or Big Blush Book Volume III

Another easy choice here. The Big Book (like the name suggests) is massive and fairly bulky. I’ve also heard these aren’t the same quality as their individual full sized counterparts, which is why I’ll be purchasing the Bazaar palette instead – it’s more compact and comes with a good selection of blushes, as well as two highlights. If I can’t get my hands on it when it lands in store, I’d consider picking up the Cheek Charmers set, as it’s one I can easily separate into gifts for myself and friends.

Tarte Holiday 2017 ToT

Image source: Tarte Cosmetics

Anastasia Beverly Hills: Holiday Blush or Sugar Glow Kit

As someone who has tried and loves the Nicole Guerriero Glow Kit, the Sugar Glow Kit is definitely one I’d like to pick up if I have any money left after the holidays! Two of the shades are definitely more fair-skin friendly, and the other two would work as blush toppers. I also like the packaging comes with removable pans, so I can pop these in with other travel palettes as needed. I think the lighter blush kit would be nice for my skin tone, but my blushes from the Stila 2015 Holiday ‘A Whole Lot of Love’ set are close dupes.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Holiday 2017 ToT

Image source: Anastasia Beverly Hills

What are you picking up and leaving behind this holiday season? Let me know in the comments below!

6 thoughts on “This or That? Tag: Holiday Makeup 2017

  1. Pingback: Tarte Blush Bazaar palette: review & swatches | Amy adores makeup

  2. If you had to pick a palette, the tarte, hourglass, or Becca, which one would you choose? I am trying to choose between the three and I would love to hear your thoughts and pros and cons of each. Thank you!


  3. If you had to choose, which palette would you buy out of the tarte, hourglass, and becca? I have been deciding between which three myself, but cannot decide and would love to hear your thoughts and pros and cons. Thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Good question Megan! I have purchased both the Becca and Hourglass palettes (reviews of both are on my blog if you want a breakdown of each). But if I could only have one, I’d go for the Hourglass because you get two blushes, a bronzer, a highlighter and two finishing powders, making it the most versatile of the three 🙂 hope that helps!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s